Literature Review

Critically Evaluating A Journal Article

Critical Reviews of Journal Articles Critical Reviews of Journal Articles

Critically Evaluating A Journal Article

Its strengths and weaknesses are assessed, followed by its overall value. What methods were used to accomplish this purpose (systematic recording of observations, analysis and evaluation of published research, assessment of theory)? Look at methods. Record your impressions and note sections suitable for quoting.

What statistical tests were used to evaluate the signicance of the conclusions based on numeric or graphic data? How did each result contribute to answering the question or testing the hypothesis raised in the introduction? How were the results interpreted? How were they related to the original problem (authors view of evidence rather than objective ndings)? Look at discussion. If your lecturer has given you specic advice on how to write a critical review, follow that advice. Use the answers to questions establish the signicance of the research to develop this section.

If your instructor is concerned that that the article be clearly situated within the social and intellectual research context, then you might present it in the following way in the introduction, cite the journal article in full and then provide the background to this piece of research, establishing its place within the eld. . Does the title or legend accurately describe the content? Are column headings and labels accurate? Are the data organized for ready comparison and interpretation? (a table should be self-explanatory, with a title that accurately and concisely describes content and column headings that accurately describe information in the cells.

When thinking of a thesis, consider the authors intentions and whether or not you think those intentions were successfully realized. The review article will provide background information for your analysis, as well as establishing that the research paper you are critiquing is signicant if the paper was not so highly regarded, it would not have been selected to be reviewed. To establish the research context, questions such as the following should be addressed was this research pertinent only within the authors geographic locale, or did it have broader (even global) relevance? Were many other laboratories pursuing related research when the reported work was done? If so, why? For experimental research, what funding sources met the costs of the research? Was the selection of the research topic inuenced by the source of research funding? On what prior observations was the research based? What was and was not known at the time? For more detailed information on how to answer these questions, see labs 4 and 5 (wood, 2003).

If your lecturer does not assign a topic or a particular article for you to review, and you must choose a topic yourself, try using a review article from your eld. Does the information seem well-researched or is it unsupported? What are the authors central arguments or conclusions? Are they clearly stated? Are they supported by evidence and analysis? If the article reports on an experiment or study, does the author clearly outline methodology and the expected result? Is the article lacking information or argumentation that you expected to find? Does the writers style suit the intended audience? Is the style stilted or unnecessarily complicated? If illustrations or charts are used, are they effective in presenting information? Read over your notes. When choosing a research article, examine the materials & methods section closely and make sure you have a good grasp of the techniques and methods used.

Does the text complement, and not simple repeat, data? Are there discrepancies between the results in the text and those in the tables? Review the results in light of the stated objectives. Evaluate each section of the article introduction, methods, results, discussion highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each section. Were the author(s) able to answer the question (test the hypothesis) raised? Did the research provide new factual information, a new understanding of a phenomenon in the eld, a new research technique? Did the reported observationsinterpretations support or refute observations or interpretations made by other researchers? (adapted with permission of professor susan lollis, family relations and applied nutrition, university of guelph. Be sure to ask your instructor which citation style to use. The second part, writing your critique, discusses two possible ways to structure your critique paper.


Using a Scientific Journal Article to Write a Critical Review | Library


A. Researching the Critique. Select a Topic. Select a Research Article. Analyse the Text. Establish the Research Context. Evaluate the Text. Establish the Significance of the Research.

Critically Evaluating A Journal Article

Critical Reviews - Introduction to Research - Research Guides at ...
28 Jul 2017 ... A critical review of a journal article evaluates the strengths and weaknesses of an article's ideas and content. It provides description, analysis and interpretation that allow readers to assess the article's value.
Critically Evaluating A Journal Article 13 Feb 2009. Use the answers to the questions in the section analyze the text to develop the summary. In order to write a critical analysis of an article, you need to take several. How To Critique A Journal Article. For frequently used style guides consult queens university librarys ideally, you should leave your first draft for a day or two before revising. Is the sample selection adequate? Is the experimental design sound? Check the sequence of statements in the methods. But wait, Is all the material organized under the appropriate headings? Are sections divided logically into subsections or paragraphs? Finally, it is important to establish whether the research has been successful has it led to new questions being asked, new ways of using existing knowledge? Are other researchers citing this paper? How did other researchers view the signicance of the research reported by your authors? Did the research reported in your article result in the formulation of new questions or hypotheses (by the authors, by other researchers)? Have other researchers subsequently supported or refuted the observationsinterpretations of these authors? What are the social, political, technological.
  • How To Critique A Journal Article


    Does it match the one in the introduction? Check the sequence of statements in the introduction. Is all the material organized under the appropriate headings? Are sections divided logically into subsections or paragraphs? Finally, it is important to establish whether the research has been successful has it led to new questions being asked, new ways of using existing knowledge? Are other researchers citing this paper? How did other researchers view the signicance of the research reported by your authors? Did the research reported in your article result in the formulation of new questions or hypotheses (by the authors, by other researchers)? Have other researchers subsequently supported or refuted the observationsinterpretations of these authors? What are the social, political, technological, medical implications of this research? To answer these questions look at review articles to nd out how reviewers see this piece of research. Review articles summarize and evaluate current studies (research articles) on a particular topic. Does all the information belong there? Is the sequence of methods clear and pertinent? Examine carefully the data as presented in the tables and diagrams. This allows you to gain a more objective perspective on your ideas.

    The review article will provide background information for your analysis, as well as establishing that the research paper you are critiquing is signicant if the paper was not so highly regarded, it would not have been selected to be reviewed. As you read the article(s) use the following questions to help you understand how and why the research was carried out. What statistical tests were used to evaluate the signicance of the conclusions based on numeric or graphic data? How did each result contribute to answering the question or testing the hypothesis raised in the introduction? How were the results interpreted? How were they related to the original problem (authors view of evidence rather than objective ndings)? Look at discussion. Use the review article to select a research article. Consult web of science to see if other writers have cited the authors work.

    Does the study reveal what the researcher intended? Check the interpretation against the results. Does all the information lead coherently to the purpose of the study? Review all methods in relation to the objective(s) of the study. To establish the research context, questions such as the following should be addressed was this research pertinent only within the authors geographic locale, or did it have broader (even global) relevance? Were many other laboratories pursuing related research when the reported work was done? If so, why? For experimental research, what funding sources met the costs of the research? Was the selection of the research topic inuenced by the source of research funding? On what prior observations was the research based? What was and was not known at the time? For more detailed information on how to answer these questions, see labs 4 and 5 (wood, 2003). Do not be confused by the term critique it does not mean that you only look at the negative aspects of what the researcher has done. The second part, writing your critique, discusses two possible ways to structure your critique paper. When thinking of a thesis, consider the authors intentions and whether or not you think those intentions were successfully realized. Bringing up scientists in the art of critiquing research. You are expected to read the article carefully, analyse it, and evaluate the quality and originality of the research, as well as its relevance and presentation. Writing a critical review of a journal article can help to improve your research skills. A critical review of a journal article evaluates the strengths and weaknesses of an articles ideas and content.

    How To Critique A Journal Article. Sponsored by ... But wait, what kind of a journal article is it: an empirical/research article, or a ... Then read it again, critically.

    Critically Reading Journal Articles

    journal. Here are a few tips that should assist you in critically evaluating the research articles you read. The Title. Read the title carefully: more information is ...
  • Essays
  • Transitional Words For Essays
  • Expository Essays
  • Transitional Words For Essay
  • Analytical Essay
  • Academic Article Writing
  • Jama Article Submission
  • Summarizing Journal Articles
  • How To Write A Summary Of A Scientific Article
  • Article In The Paper
  • Essays Writers

    Evaluate each section of the article introduction, methods, results, discussion highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each section. Check for the following when revising you may make major revisions in the organization or content of your review during the revision process. You have completed your analysis and evaluation of the journal article. Use the answers to questions establish the signicance of the research to develop this section. You should address both the positive and negative aspects.

    Look at research articles to see how other people have used this work what range of journals have cited this article? For more detailed information on how to answer these questions, see lab Buy now Critically Evaluating A Journal Article

    Writing Essays Tips

    Does all the information lead coherently to the purpose of the study? Review all methods in relation to the objective(s) of the study. If your lecturer does not assign a topic or a particular article for you to review, and you must choose a topic yourself, try using a review article from your eld. Use the review article to select a research article. If you dont, you may have diculty evaluating them. This allows you to gain a more objective perspective on your ideas.

    Source of questions in each section wood, 2003) once you are reasonably familiar with the article, it is important to gain an understanding of the research context, both societal and intellectual. Eliminate all notes that do not relate to your thesis Critically Evaluating A Journal Article Buy now

    Buy Custom Essays Online

    Organize your remaining points into separate groups such as points about structure, style, or argument. As you read the article(s) use the following questions to help you understand how and why the research was carried out. If your lecturer has given you specic advice on how to write a critical review, follow that advice. Note use the same bibliographic citation format as you would for any bibliography, works cited or reference list. Revising can even lead to a radical change in your central thesis.

    When choosing a research article, examine the materials & methods section closely and make sure you have a good grasp of the techniques and methods used. What objective evidence was obtained from the authors eorts (observations, measurements etc Buy Critically Evaluating A Journal Article at a discount

    Third Person Essay Writing

    This allows you to gain a more objective perspective on your ideas. The review should begin with a complete citation of the article. What was the objective of the study? Read the statement of purpose in the abstract. Does the information seem well-researched or is it unsupported? What are the authors central arguments or conclusions? Are they clearly stated? Are they supported by evidence and analysis? If the article reports on an experiment or study, does the author clearly outline methodology and the expected result? Is the article lacking information or argumentation that you expected to find? Does the writers style suit the intended audience? Is the style stilted or unnecessarily complicated? If illustrations or charts are used, are they effective in presenting information? Read over your notes Buy Online Critically Evaluating A Journal Article

    Famous Quotes For Essay Writing

    Does it match the one in the introduction? Check the sequence of statements in the introduction. Read the statement of purpose at the end of the introduction. Use the answers to the questions in evaluate the text to develop this section. Use the answers to questions establish the signicance of the research to develop this section. What was the objective of the study? Read the statement of purpose in the abstract.

    Review the results as presented in the text while referring to the data in the tables and diagrams. By assessing the work of others, you develop skills as a critical reader and become familiar with the types of evaluation criteria that will be applied to research in your eld and thus your own research Buy Critically Evaluating A Journal Article Online at a discount

    Best Topic For Essay Writing

    A critical review of a journal article evaluates the strengths and weaknesses of an articles ideas and content. Are the methods valid for studying the problem? Check the methods for essential information. Note prepared by university of toronto mississauga library, hazel mccallion academic learning centre. If you dont, you may have diculty evaluating them. Note use the same bibliographic citation format as you would for any bibliography, works cited or reference list.

    Be sure to ask your instructor which citation style to use. If your instructor is concerned that that the article be clearly situated within the social and intellectual research context, then you might present it in the following way in the introduction, cite the journal article in full and then provide the background to this piece of research, establishing its place within the eld Critically Evaluating A Journal Article For Sale

    Open University Essay Writing

    ). Use the answers to questions establish the signicance of the research to develop this section. Study the list of references to determine what research contributed to the authors arguments. You are expected to read the article carefully, analyse it, and evaluate the quality and originality of the research, as well as its relevance and presentation. Does the information seem well-researched or is it unsupported? What are the authors central arguments or conclusions? Are they clearly stated? Are they supported by evidence and analysis? If the article reports on an experiment or study, does the author clearly outline methodology and the expected result? Is the article lacking information or argumentation that you expected to find? Does the writers style suit the intended audience? Is the style stilted or unnecessarily complicated? If illustrations or charts are used, are they effective in presenting information? Read over your notes For Sale Critically Evaluating A Journal Article

    Best College Application Essay

    When thinking of a thesis, consider the authors intentions and whether or not you think those intentions were successfully realized. What methods were used to accomplish this purpose (systematic recording of observations, analysis and evaluation of published research, assessment of theory)? Look at methods. After you have read the article and answered the questions in the previous section, you should have a good understanding of the research undertaken. Revising can even lead to a radical change in your central thesis. It provides description, analysis and interpretation that allow readers to assess the articles value.

    A critical review of a journal article evaluates the strengths and weaknesses of an articles ideas and content Sale Critically Evaluating A Journal Article

    MENU

    Home

    Paper

    Coursework

    Biographies

    Writing

    Capstone

    Bibliography

    Letter

    Dissertation

    Term paper

    Literature

    What Is A Citation In Writing Essay

    Essay Writing About Mother

    Freedom Writers Essay Introduction

    Write My Essay For Money

    How To Write University Essay

    How To Write A Similarities And Differences Essay

    Writing A Film Analysis Essay

    Best College Application Essay

    What Is The Best Custom Essay Writing Service

    My Childhood Essay Writing

    Academic Essay Writing Tips

    How To Write An Admission Essay For Graduate School

    Easy Essay Writer

    How To Write Good English Essays

    How To Write An Essay About My School

    Literature Review
    sitemap

    SPONSOR